The Significance of Vortex Ring Formation to Pulsatile Jet Propulsion

Paul Krueger

Graduate Aeronautical Laboratories
Caltech

Abstract-
Although jet propulsion is commonly associated with aeronautics, the concept of jet propulsion was pioneered by aquatic creatures such as squid and jellyfish. In this setting, jet propulsion consists of periodic ejection of fluid from an orifice or tube, which is commonly associated with the formation of vortex rings. The recent work of Gharib, Rambod, and Shariff [JFM, 360 (1998)] has shown that vortex rings formed by ejecting fluid from a tube using a piston-cylinder mechanism stop growing and pinch off from their generating jet for sufficiently large values of the piston stroke to diameter ratio (L/D), suggesting a maximization principle may exist for propulsion utilizing starting jets. The analysis of Weihs [Fortschr. der Zoo., 24 (1977)] suggests propulsive benefits may also be obtained from rapid ejection of pulses due to the increased translational velocity of the resulting vortex rings derived from their mutual interaction. To study the significance of these issues to propulsion, a piston-cylinder mechanism attached to a force balance is used to investigate the impulse and thrust generated by starting jets at L/D ratios in the range 2 to 8. Fully-pulsed jets comprised of a periodic series of starting jets are also considered for non-dimensional frequencies, StL, in the range 0.1 to 0.97, where 1.0 is the maximum value attainable by a fully-pulsed jet. Measurements of the impulse associated with vortex ring formation show it to be much larger than that expected from the jet velocity alone and proportionately larger than that associated with a trailing jet for L/D large enough to observe pinch off. The latter result leads to a local maximum in the average thrust during a pulse at L/D values associated with vortex rings whose circulation has been maximized. The characteristics of vortex ring formation leading to this optimal condition will be discussed with the aid of energy and circulation measurements obtained using DPIV. Measurements of the time averaged thrust of fully-pulsed jets confirm the relative significance of vortex ring formation to propulsion over that of a trailing jet for all StL, but indicate that the thrust benefit obtained is generally reduced as StL increases. Mechanisms by which preceding pulses interfere with vortex ring formation will be presented to explain this reduction with StL. The propulsive benefits predicted by Weihs are not observed, and the flow characteristics governing this unexpected result will be discussed.


GALCIT Home Page
2000-2001 Fluids Seminar Page


Maintained by: Tait Pottebaum
EMail: Tait Pottebaum
Last modified: April 30, 2001